Candy Day candy@healthlink.org.za
How good is the evidence? Checking the validity of information found
Clearly it is crucial that if one is going to base health care decisions on "evidence" found in various information sources, that the validity of this information can be assessed. The International Congress on Biomedical Peer Review and Global Communications <http://www.ama-assn.org/public/peer/peerhome.htm > aimed to evaluate peer review as a tool for assessing the quality and credibility of scientific information, to help close the information gap between the East and West and the South and North, and to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of global biomedical communications. The strength of evidence depends on many factors, and no discussion on evidence-based medicine would be complete without mention of the efforts of the Cochrane Collaboration.
Reviews of the Evidence Cochrane Collaboration & others
"To make well-informed decisions about health care, clinicians, policy makers, funders and patients need access to reliable evidence about the effects of health care interventions. Unfortunately people are often not aware of the evidence that is available, the evidence is disorganised and inaccessible, or it simply does not exist." (About the Cochrane Collaboration, South African Health Technology Monitor, Vol 1, No 1, July 1997, Medical Research Council monitor@eagle.mrc.ac.za )
The Cochrane Collaboration < http://hiru.mcmaster.ca/cochrane > facilitates the creation, review, maintenance and dissemination of systematic overviews of the effects of health care interventions.
The Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effectiveness (DARE) < http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/crd/info > is a collection of records of good quality research reviews of the effectiveness of health care interventions, and the management and organisation of health services.
Whilst reviews would be expected to provide a more balanced view of the evidence, it is clear that techniques such as meta-analysis are still beset by problems (Meta-analysis: Unresolved issues and future developments. BMJ 1998;316:221-225 (17 January), http://www.bmj.com/ ). We also have to be careful that "evidence" doesnt become the only focus. As Kerridge et al point out, at the individual level, the presence of reliable evidence does not ensure that better decisions will be made, and at the level of national policy determination and resource allocation evidence is available for relatively few interventions. Looking only to evidence-based medicine is seeking simplistic solutions to inherently complex problems (BMJ 1998;316:1151 http://www.bmj.com ).
Evidence Based Drug Therapy
Evidence based medicine is really a principle that should be applied to all health professions and aspects of health care. Evidence based drug therapy is just one example of particular relevance to the pharmacist.
A number of sites look at the pharmacological implications of evidence based practice:
National Prescribing Centre [UK] < http://www.npc.co.uk >
Therapeutics Initiative Home Page [Canada] < http://www.interchg.ubc.ca/jauca/ >
PreMeC [New Zealand] < http://www.premec.org.nz >
Evidence Based Health Discussion List
Evidence based health (EBH) is the application of critical appraisal to problems in health care. This list is for teachers and practitioners in health related fields. To subscribe send an email with the message join evidence-based-health to mailbase@mailbase.ac.uk
Medical Search Engines / Catalogues:
Health A to Z http://www.healthatoz.com
MedwebSA http://www.medwebsa.co.za (in development, useful potential)
Medical World Search http://www.mwsearch.com
MedFinder Smart Medical Web Search http://www.netmedicine.com/medfinder.htm
MedSite Medical Search Engine http://www.medsite.com
CliniWeb http://www.ohsu.edu/cliniweb/ is an index and table of contents to clinical information on the Web.
General Search EnginesThere has been a proliferation of search engines on the Internet. Many of them index billions of pages, which are visited regularly by "spiders" or "robots" (eg HotBot), while others adopt a more catalogue-oriented approach (eg Yahoo) where entries are organised by broad categories which drill down. There are also variations in the power of the search engines, some allowing complex Boolean searches, categorisation by location and other factors. The search engine which I personally have found to have the best mix of speed, ease of use and functionality is HotBot.
HotBot http://hotbot.com
Altavista http://www.altavista.digital.com
Yahoo http://www.yahoo.com
DogPile http://www.dogpile.com
African / South African Search Sites:
Ananzi http://www.ananzi.co.za
Internet Gateway to South Africa http://www.minotaur.marques.co.za
Rubani http://www.rubani.com
ZaZoo http://www.mweb.co.za/zazoo
Other Resources
Medical Matrix < http://www.medmatrix.org > has ranked, peer-reviewed, annotated, updated clinical medicine resources
The Health Information Research Unit < http://hiru.mcmaster.ca/ > studies the phenomenology of health information, develops information tools to support evidence-based medicine and evaluates informational health interventions
Information or Disinformation?
In a short article on "The changing face of Information: Balancing the power of new techniques versus the credibility of established methodology" http://www.healthlink.org.za/hlink/info/internet1.htm , some of these issues were addressed:
| Home | Organisation
| Activities | Policy | Links | Search |
webmaster@saahip.org.za